CM

Cassandra M

Service Advisor
Évaluation globale
Évaluation globale 4,7/5Évaluation globale 4,7/5Évaluation globale 4,7/5Évaluation globale 4,7/5Évaluation globale 4,7/5
4,7
(27 reviews)
85

PR
gravatar
Patricia R.
Stony Brook, NY
Évaluation globale 4,0/5Évaluation globale 4,0/5Évaluation globale 4,0/5Évaluation globale 4,0/5Évaluation globale 4,0/5
01/09/2026
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
Always professional!
Extremely helpful😊
Quick turnaround time!

CF
Charles F.
Saint James, NY
Évaluation globale 1,0/5Évaluation globale 1,0/5Évaluation globale 1,0/5Évaluation globale 1,0/5Évaluation globale 1,0/5
01/08/2026
client vérifiéVérifié Client
0
Very bad
My car was brought there for a battery and alternator. They wanted to charge me over $1,550 for this service. I brought the car to another car service station and they only charged me $650. In addition, they seem to pad the labor hours when performing the service, telling me it takes 40 minutes to change a battery. It takes at most 10 minutes, I have done it many times.
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 01/09/2026 04:57 AM

Regarding Your Recent Visit and Feedback

Dear Charles,

We are responding to your recent feedback to clarify the facts surrounding your visit.

Your junk vehicle has over 250,000 miles, and during your visit we diagnosed a failed alternator and battery. We presented you with multiple repair options, including the option of installing a used alternator to reduce cost. You declined all repair options and chose not to proceed with any work.

A diagnostic fee was charged for the time and expertise required to properly evaluate the vehicle. As with all customers, this fee applies regardless of AAA membership, as our technicians do not work without compensation. In addition we are glad you found a shop that suites your wallet.

Submitting a negative survey despite declining repairs does not accurately reflect the services provided or the options offered. We acted professionally, transparently, and in good faith throughout your visit.

We stand by our diagnosis, our pricing, and our business practices.

Sincerely,
A Scaglione 

Employés avec lesquels vous avez travaillé

FC
gravatar
Francis C.
Nesconset, NY
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
01/07/2026
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
review
review
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 01/09/2026 09:42 AM

We appreciate your five-star review! It’s great to hear that your experience with us was excellent. We strive to make every visit as smooth as a freshly oiled engine, and feedback like yours fuels our drive to keep up the good work. If you ever need anything, don’t hesitate to reach out!

Employés avec lesquels vous avez travaillé

RG
Robert G.
Saint James, NY
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
01/02/2026
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
Great service
Great service and quality
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 01/04/2026 09:37 AM

We really appreciate your positive feedback! It's wonderful to hear that you found our service and quality to be top-notch. We're always here to keep your wheels turning smoothly – and hopefully with a smile or two along the way. Don't hesitate to come back whenever you need us!

Employés avec lesquels vous avez travaillé

NB
NANCY B.
Centereach, NY
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
12/30/2025
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
Complete vehicle maintenance.
The Smithwest team are honest, efficient and thorough. If you want quality work without the headache.
Rush over to Smithwest in St. James.
You will not want any of your vehicles serviced anywhere else!
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 12/31/2025 08:58 AM

It's great to hear that you had such a positive experience with the Smithwest team! We pride ourselves on being the honest mechanics you can trust to get the job done right, all without giving you a headache – unless, of course, you're in a traffic jam on the way here! Your confidence in us means a lot, and we look forward to keeping your vehicle in tip-top shape. Remember, we’re just a pit stop away from more quality work ahead!


AW
Andrew W.
Hauppauge, NY
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
12/30/2025
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
The Best Auto Shop on the East Coast
They’re loyal and extremely caring for your vehicle. Hands down the best service shop I’ve been to on the East Coast.
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 12/31/2025 08:58 AM

We really appreciate your feedback! It's great to hear that you feel our service is top-notch. We always aim to treat every vehicle as if it were our own, and it sounds like we hit the mark with you. If our service is the best on the East Coast, we may have to start charging a toll for all the vehicular traffic coming our way! Thanks for choosing us to take care of your car.


TM
Thomas M.
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
12/05/2025
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
Fine Service
Smithwest Service does great work! I have been dealing with them for several years and have always been please with their services’
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 12/07/2025 09:41 AM

We appreciate your continued support over the years and are delighted to hear that our team has consistently met your expectations. Your loyalty is invaluable to us, and it appears that the quality of our services has been a winning ticket in your automotive journey. Should you require our assistance in the future, we are more than ready to provide the same high standard of service that you have come to expect. Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Keep on driving safely!


RC
Ricii C.
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
12/05/2025
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
Gl550 service
Cassandra was a pleasure to deal with, when I have more services needed I will be back
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 12/07/2025 09:41 AM

We are delighted to hear that your experience with Cassandra was as enjoyable as a well-timed punchline in a comedy show. Her dedication to customer service certainly shines through, and it is wonderful to know that she made a positive impression. We look forward to assisting you with any future services you may require. Your trust in us is greatly valued, and we are here to ensure you receive the same level of exceptional care every time you visit.

Employés avec lesquels vous avez travaillé

EC
Elisabeth C.
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
11/21/2025
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
General maintenance and oil change
I brought my cay car in for an oil change and a general upkeep check and I was very satisfied with the service at Smitheest Service Center. They were veer very accommodating and did a good job. I will definitely go back again.
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 11/21/2025 09:24 AM

We appreciate your feedback regarding your recent visit to Smithwest Service Center. It is always gratifying to hear that our team was able to accommodate your needs effectively while providing excellent service. We take great pride in ensuring that every vehicle receives the care and attention it deserves. It seems that your car received the royal treatment, and we are glad to have played a part in its upkeep! Should you require further assistance or have any more maintenance needs in the future, our doors are always open. Drive safely!

Employés avec lesquels vous avez travaillé

SD
Suzanne D.
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
11/15/2025
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
pleased with staff and service
The staff at Smithwest are professional and explain everything to you before they start any work on your car. they also print out a detailed receipt with the work that was done and include a separate list of things that your car will need to get done in the near future.
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 11/17/2025 04:36 AM

We appreciate your feedback regarding your experience at Smithwest Service Center. It is heartening to hear that our team’s professionalism and clear communication left a positive impression on you. We believe that understanding the work being performed on your vehicle is crucial, and it seems that our detailed approach aligns with your expectations. In addition, we take pride in providing a thorough receipt, including future recommendations, to help you stay ahead of the curve regarding your car's maintenance needs. After all, a well-informed customer is a happy customer, and we like to think of ourselves as your automotive advisors, not just your mechanics. We look forward to ensuring your vehicle continues to run smoothly and efficiently in the future.

Employés avec lesquels vous avez travaillé

CK
Cynthia K.
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
11/13/2025
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
Excellent experience!
It was such a pleasure dealing with Smithwest. From their honesty and pictures of car parts that needed to be fixed, to ordering me an Uber and having an after-hours box to pick up keys and paperwork, everything was seamless. Such a better experience than going to the dealership.
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 11/14/2025 05:34 AM

We appreciate your positive feedback regarding your experience with Smithwest Service Center. It is gratifying to hear that you found our approach to maintaining transparency through honest communication and providing visual documentation of the necessary repairs helpful. We strive to make the process as seamless as possible, and it is encouraging to know that the arrangements for transportation and our after-hours services met your expectations. Your comparison to dealership experiences highlights our commitment to providing a customer-centric service. Thank you for choosing us for your automotive needs; your trust and satisfaction are of utmost importance to us.

Employés avec lesquels vous avez travaillé

LM
Lori M.
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
10/22/2025
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
Mrs Mahoney
Very pleased with the work and the timely repair. Good to have a nearby shop I can feel comfortable with for future repairs.
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 10/22/2025 12:58 PM

We sincerely appreciate your positive feedback regarding your recent experience at Smithwest Service Center. It is always our goal to provide timely and high-quality repairs, so it is gratifying to know that we have met your expectations on this occasion. Knowing that you feel comfortable with us for future repairs is the highest compliment we could receive, and it assures us that our efforts are effective. Should you require our services again, rest assured that we will be here, ready to ensure your vehicle stays in top shape. Happy driving!


AS
ANTHONY S.
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
10/09/2025
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
Honest, Reliable, Quality
SmithWest is an Honest, Reliable and Quality repair shop. My father brought his Mercedes back to the dealership for a minor gas leak and wanted to charge over $2k for the repair. After speaking with Cassandra who is always pleasant and accommodating, We dropped the car off for Angelo and his team to look at. After inspection, the repair was done for more than 50% less than Mercedes. I highly recommend SmithWest and trust them with all mine and my families vehicles.
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 10/10/2025 05:30 AM

Your positive feedback about Smithwest Service Center is greatly appreciated. It's wonderful to hear that Cassandra’s pleasant demeanor made the process easier for you, and that Angelo and the team were able to provide such a cost-effective solution. We always aim to keep our customers' wallets a bit heavier while ensuring their vehicles are in excellent shape. Thank you for placing your trust in us; we look forward to continuing to serve you and your family in the future!

Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 10/16/2025 06:59 AM

Dear Valued Customer,

 

We sincerely appreciate you’re taking the time to complete the survey regarding your recent experience with Smithwest Service Center Inc. Your feedback is incredibly valuable to us and helps us continually improve our services to better meet your needs.

 

We are delighted to hear that you had a great experience with us. At Smithwest Service Center Inc., we strive to provide exceptional service, and your positive comments motivate our team to maintain the highest standards of quality and customer satisfaction.

 

If there is anything further, we can do to assist you or if you have additional suggestions, please do not hesitate to reach out personally at aaa@smithwestauto.com. We look forward to serving you again in the future.

 

Thank you once again for your kind words and for choosing Smithwest Service Center Inc.

 

Warm regards,  

 

Angelo S

President/CEO

Smithwest Service Center Inc.  


RC
RICH C.
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
09/22/2025
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
Coil repair
They diagnosed the problem which didn’t take long and presented a resolution. Quick, easy and painless unlike Mercedes Benz dealerships
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 09/23/2025 05:04 AM

Thank you for your positive feedback. We are pleased to hear that you found our diagnostic process efficient and that we were able to provide a satisfactory resolution. It is our goal to ensure a seamless experience for our customers, and your comments affirm our commitment to that aim. If you have any further needs in the future, we are here to assist you.

Employés avec lesquels vous avez travaillé

MM
MARY ANNE M.
Évaluation globale 2,0/5Évaluation globale 2,0/5Évaluation globale 2,0/5Évaluation globale 2,0/5Évaluation globale 2,0/5
09/22/2025
client vérifiéVérifié Client
0
Inspection
Not a good experience. The counter person was not friendly nor professional. I did not feel valued as a customer.
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 09/23/2025 05:23 AM

  Mary Anne, thank you for your feedback. We're sorry to hear that you felt your experience did not meet expectations. During your visit, our team completed your New York State Inspection and replaced your serpentine belt that was cracked. We also noted that your oil change service was over due based on age and that both your engine air filter and cabin air filter had not been changed since January 2022 which are both dirty/clogged. 

We understand that these recommendations may feel overwhelming, but they're critical for the health and safety of your vehicle. Our intention is to never to come across as unfriendly, but to provide honest guidance. Even when a vehicle isnt driven often, or doesnt meet the 3,000-5,000 mile mark, oil can break down and absorb moisture over time, which leads to harmful build up.

We truly value your business and appreciate the opportunity to serve you. 

Employés avec lesquels vous avez travaillé

MR
MIKE R.
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
08/19/2025
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
Always professional
Never dissatisfied. Work that is done is always explained thoroughly
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 08/20/2025 04:47 AM

We appreciate your feedback! It is our pleasure to provide detailed explanations along with our services, ensuring that you feel right at home and informed while your vehicle is in our care. 🚗 We're committed to maintaining this level of satisfaction and transparency. It's all about keeping those wheels turning smoothly! 😊


PS
PAUL S.
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
07/23/2025
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
It was very good
You are extremely knowledgeable both times I brought my vehicles in and told you what I thought the problem was ,you diagnosed it right away your service was terrific my brother-in-law recommended you to me and I’m glad that he did will continue to bring my vehicles to you
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 07/24/2025 06:48 AM

We appreciate your positive feedback regarding your experiences at Smithwest Service Center. It is gratifying to know that you found our diagnostic services to be accurate and our overall service to be of high quality. Your brother-in-law's recommendation is valued, and it is an honor to earn your trust as a repeat customer. Our team is dedicated to providing precise and reliable solutions for all vehicle concerns, and we look forward to assisting you with any future needs. Thank you for choosing us for your automotive services.

Employés avec lesquels vous avez travaillé

CP
CHRISTINA P.
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
07/23/2025
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
Complete Break Repair
Absolutely recommend these guys. My breaks failed on the way to work, needed a complete repair and flush of my break system, not only did they tow my car within 20 mins, they got my car back to me within 24 hours like brand new for an unbeatable price.
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 07/24/2025 06:50 AM

We are grateful for your recommendation! It's great to know that we could assist you promptly when you needed it most. Our team strives to provide efficient service, and we’re pleased that your brakes were repaired quickly and effectively. Your encouraging words mean a lot to us. If you have any further needs, don't hesitate to reach out! 🚗🔧

Employés avec lesquels vous avez travaillé

BW
BRIAN W.
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
07/16/2025
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
Great team!
Smithwest does an awesome job. Very trustworthy and always able to work within my schedule.
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 07/17/2025 08:29 AM

We appreciate you sharing your experience with us! It’s great to hear that you find our service trustworthy and that we’re able to accommodate your schedule. Our team strives to provide the best service possible, and feedback like yours motivates us to keep up the good work. 🚗✨


JR
JOHN R.
Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5Évaluation globale 5,0/5
06/26/2025
client vérifiéVérifié Client
10
Another Car Problem Solved
Punctured a tire on my way to work on Wednesday. Tire did not flatten right away and I wasn't aware of the problem until I was going home. It was too late to get it fixed then, so I figured just bring it to SSC Thursday morning. Without an appointment, I knew I would be in for a wait. They were able to fix the tire faster than they said.
I am always happy with the service I get here.
Angelo S., Owner/Operator de Smithwest Service Center a répondu le 06/26/2025 12:57 PM

We appreciate your feedback regarding your recent experience at Smithwest Service Center. It’s great to hear that we could address your tire issue efficiently, especially given the circumstances. We strive to provide prompt service and it's satisfying to know that we could exceed your expectations this time. 🚗🔧 Your trust means a lot to us, and we value your continued support.

Employés avec lesquels vous avez travaillé
Net Promoter® NPS®, NPS Prism® et les émoticônes associées au NPS sont des marques déposées de Bain & Company, Inc., Satmetrix Systems, Inc. et Fred Reichheld. Net Promoter Score™ et Net Promoter System™ sont des marques de service de Bain & Company, Inc. et Fred Reichheld.